Sign in or 

|
hdgcat |
3594. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 1:09 AM EST
"Hey All, over on Dallas' website there is a place to ask questions of CH for an upcoming interview. I asked if I have been reading the books all wrong or if I had misinterpreted Eric since she supposedly said she didn't get why fans liked him so much.How did you phrase the question? It could be hard for her to see what you're actually asking. If you [phrased it the way you just posted it, it almost sounds like you think something about Eric is completely obvious,but she may not understand that if she doesn't see him that way. Am I making sense? I don't know where anyone gets that CH has a problem with Eric. If you read/watch interviews with her over the years, she's been very consistent with how she talks about him. This is what she said about hiim in the EW vampire issue this past summer: "I decided Bill's boss would be Bill's opposite in most ways. Blond,tall,imperious, and in some ways surprisingly liberated, Eric almost leaped into the story" . I think this is a fantastic description of him. And she's stated that he's fun to write, But she's still NOT going ot see him the way some readers do. I love ERic ,but I don't love him the way some others do. I love Bill, but I would not claim to love him the way Bill'sbabes do. We all bring our own baggage to the table so to speak and none of us are going to see these characters the same way. Do you find this valuable? |
|
hdgcat |
3595. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 1:43 AM EST
"l. Part of Bill LOVES it when Sookie is beaten down, injured or scared etc. I think it's part of Bill's personality to want to be the protector type guy, which is not all bad. I think Sookie is -- normally -- a little too strong, too self reliant or independent to match up well with Bill. Bill enjoys Sookie's weakness; Eric enjoys Sookie's strength. "I think its more along the line that Bill loves being the one to take care of her cuz he might think that no one will see to her needs as well as he does. I think thats why he was hanging around after the Quinn fight ,remember Eric said he had trouble getting Bill to leave? Bill couldn't accept the fact that Eric would/could take care of her. Yes,Sookie is strong but she's had to be and she is fragile as well. Bill sees the part thats fragile ,chipped and broken and loves her anyway. I'm not so sure Eric sees that side of her . He loves her strength ,he's uncomfortable with her frailties. In the hospital he was uneasy when she started crying again. he assured her he was proud of her strength cuz thats what he can understand and deal with.(typical Viking! LOL!) Here's a question: why do you see Bill as unaccepting of Sook as strong? I'm trying to think of specific examples when they were dating. He never asked her to quit her job, micro manage her life, he asked her to live with him but that was after dating for months, he offered the clothes/haircut gift thing but that's fun stuff not I'm paying your bills for you cuz you can't take care of yourself stuff. I've had heated discussions with some over the Why Didn't Bill Help Sook Pay Her Bills question and to me it shows respect that she can take care of her own business. He's backed her up when she's gotten involved in some iffy ventures(Dallas). Whenm they got off the plane he told her she could handle just about anything and I think he meant it. Do you find this valuable? |
|
arwenevenstarcroft |
3596. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 3:49 AM EST
Regarding Sookie's love life --- I wonder what Charlaine is going to do with the Sam-Sookie connection. He's been such a steady, stable part of her life. In book 9, it seems to me that Eric is threatened by Quinn more than any of Sookie's other suiters. Wonder why this is. When Niall says the vampire is a good man and he loves you, who is he talking about. I just kinda assumed it was Eric. For one thing, Niall always appeared to refer to Eric as "the vampire." Alcide seems to be out of the picture - but not quite. Bill was redeemed in book 9.
Do you find this valuable?
|
|
msbuffy |
3597. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 7:25 AM EST
"Thank you,Oh - I think you would love it, IATM!! Dallas is THE "go-to-woman" for everything CH & TB. Do you find this valuable? |
|
msbuffy |
3598. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 7:38 AM EST
"well said Star,While I agree with Star's post & think that she got the nurturing part of Bill correct & that Eric is in the learning mode, I have to take up a point with your post, IATM. I've been re-reading DUD in order to make a point about some theories going on over on the Speculation thread. While Sookie does have her "jealousy issues", and they are somewhat adolescent in nature, she does not like hearing or being told that she is "MINE" whether Bill is trying to be protective or showing that he loves her. In fact, she rather resents it, and wishes that he would stop telling people that. I do agree though that by CD she begins "coming into her own" and asserting herself in a more mature way. In fact, I'd have to say that she actually flourishes without Bill. Do you find this valuable? |
|
msbuffy |
3599. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 7:47 AM EST
"How did you phrase the question? It could be hard for her to see what you're actually asking. If you [phrased it the way you just posted it, it almost sounds like you think something about Eric is completely obvious,but she may not understand that if she doesn't see him that way. Am I making sense?Agreed, Cat. I LOVE both of these characters as well, but I'm certain that I don't view them in the same way that you do, or Star does, or IATM does. I see them as the ying/yang of the vampire. One is atoning for his existance as vampire; the other celebrating his existance. Neither is wrong, neither is right. Aside from that, as love interest characters, they both carry admirable traits. That's why I remain neutral. Do you find this valuable? |
|
doohansen |
3600. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 9:43 AM EST
"How did you phrase the question? It could be hard for her to see what you're actually asking. If you [phrased it the way you just posted it, it almost sounds like you think something about Eric is completely obvious,but she may not understand that if she doesn't see him that way. Am I making sense?Ouch! Well, I actually phrased it like this. "Ms. Harris, on the most recent radio chat, you said that you didn't understand why fans liked Eric so much, I am wondering why you feel this way. After having read all the books, I feel Eric is honorable, straightforward, truthful and always there for Sookie. It seemed to me that the pairing of Eric and Sookie is the main relationship of the stories. Have I been misinterpreting him? Did I read him wrong?" I was asking how she could say that after writing him as the hero, that's all. I kind of take offense to the baggage statement. Yes, I have my views and opinions, but baggage is a bit harsh. Do you find this valuable? |
|
msbuffy |
3601. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 10:35 AM EST
"Ouch! Well, I actually phrased it like this. "Ms. Harris, on the most recent radio chat, you said that you didn't understand why fans liked Eric so much, I am wondering why you feel this way. After having read all the books, I feel Eric is honorable, straightforward, truthful and always there for Sookie. It seemed to me that the pairing of Eric and Sookie is the main relationship of the stories. Have I been misinterpreting him? Did I read him wrong?" I was asking how she could say that after writing him as the hero, that's all. I kind of take offense to the baggage statement. Yes, I have my views and opinions, but baggage is a bit harsh."Sounds like a good question to me, Doo. I hope you get an answer & are able to bring it back & share it with the rest of us! Do you find this valuable? |
|
ms.starshine |
3602. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 10:53 AM EST
"Ouch! Well, I actually phrased it like this. "Ms. Harris, on the most recent radio chat, you said that you didn't understand why fans liked Eric so much, I am wondering why you feel this way. After having read all the books, I feel Eric is honorable, straightforward, truthful and always there for Sookie. It seemed to me that the pairing of Eric and Sookie is the main relationship of the stories. Have I been misinterpreting him? Did I read him wrong?" I was asking how she could say that after writing him as the hero, that's all. I kind of take offense to the baggage statement. Yes, I have my views and opinions, but baggage is a bit harsh."like how you phrased it Doo. Seems pretty clear to me. Good question and I hope she gives you and answer. Please share it with us here if she does. Seems like all you hear these days is negative comments about Eric -- from TB people, Bill fans, even CH herself recently. Yet so many of us reading the series have fallen in love with him. Why IS there this huge disconnect between us and how others seem to see him as a bad guy?? Do you find this valuable? |
|
arwenevenstarcroft |
3603. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 11:15 AM EST
"like how you phrased it Doo. Seems pretty clear to me. Good question and I hope she gives you and answer. Please share it with us here if she does. Seems like all you hear these days is negative comments about Eric -- from TB people, Bill fans, even CH herself recently. Yet so many of us reading the series have fallen in love with him. Why IS there this huge disconnect between us and how others seem to see him as a bad guy?? "I think the question is very well phrased! And very deserving of an answer! Do you suppose part of the Eric deflation is the direct result of the fact that Charlaine has a new contract to write at least 3 more novels? I mean, maybe she is trying to draw out the suspense? I think it's fair to say that many people are into these books for the romance aspect of it. I think the question of Sookie's choice is the main draw for many readers. In either case, I don't think the author should be mocking readers and their ability to interpret what's she's writing -- if that's what she's doing. I think I'm reading what she's put on the page. I'm not desperately trying to create a fictitious romance where Charlaine didn't create one. Do you find this valuable? |
|
doohansen |
3604. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 11:25 AM EST
"Sounds like a good question to me, Doo. I hope you get an answer & are able to bring it back & share it with the rest of us!"Thanks, if I get an answer I will OF COURSE share with all my peeps. Just hate being insulted for my opinion, but that seems to be the norm with that particular poster. Do you find this valuable? |
|
ms.starshine |
3605. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 11:45 AM EST
"I think its more along the line that Bill loves being the one to take care of her cuz he might think that no one will see to her needs as well as he does. I think thats why he was hanging around after the Quinn fight ,remember Eric said he had trouble getting Bill to leave? Bill couldn't accept the fact that Eric would/could take care of her."Exactly! Your example is kind of typical of Bill's behavior IMO. 'Bill loves being the one to take care of her' so he kind of looks for situations where he can satisfy this urge. It seems we mostly agree here Cat. Yes, Bill likes Sookie's weakness-- you call it 'fragile" and that word works for me too; Eric likes her strength. The scenes where Eric is with Sookie and she's crying are often humorous to me -- he is such a typical guy there, this big bad powerful arrogant old vamp reduced to flustered mush in the face of female tears. No question Eric would much rather defend Sookie with a sword than deal with her tears. I bet he was secretly relieved when the bad fairies arrived so he could exit the emotional maelstrom and draw his sword. Not that THAT scene was funny. But remember the elevator scene? I think that was LDID? I hesitate to get into a deep discussion of Bill's issues because I always seem to get myself into trouble when I criticize Bill. He comes across to me, not to others I know, as over protective. I would point to the example you just used with Quinn. Bill was TOO eager to protect her. Both from Quinn (who was not actually attacking Sookie so Sookie didn't really need Bill's protecting) and then with Eric. Hanging out in her woods comes to mind too. He LOVES being Sookie's protector and caregiver -- sometimes too much IMO. I just see Bill as the kind of guy who would love a more dependent female. Do you find this valuable? |
|
ms.starshine |
3606. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 11:56 AM EST
"I think the question is very well phrased! And very deserving of an answer! Do you suppose part of the Eric deflation is the direct result of the fact that Charlaine has a new contract to write at least 3 more novels? I mean, maybe she is trying to draw out the suspense? I think it's fair to say that many people are into these books for the romance aspect of it. I think the question of Sookie's choice is the main draw for many readers. In either case, I don't think the author should be mocking readers and their ability to interpret what's she's writing -- if that's what she's doing. I think I'm reading what she's put on the page. I'm not desperately trying to create a fictitious romance where Charlaine didn't create one."good point arwen. Maybe CH NOW has to throw some more conflict into the series in order to extend it for 3 extra books?? So she suddenly has to give the Eric character more negatives or we would be at the happilly ever after stage and the series would be lacking romantic suspense. Kind of along these lines, I have a friend who thinks Alex S who plays Eric in TB is becoming too big a star to stay with the TV series very long and that's why TB isn't focussing more on him. Interesting idea. Do you find this valuable? |
|
arwenevenstarcroft |
3607. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 2:10 PM EST
"good point arwen. Maybe CH NOW has to throw some more conflict into the series in order to extend it for 3 extra books?? So she suddenly has to give the Eric character more negatives or we would be at the happilly ever after stage and the series would be lacking romantic suspense. Kind of along these lines, I have a friend who thinks Alex S who plays Eric in TB is becoming too big a star to stay with the TV series very long and that's why TB isn't focussing more on him. Interesting idea. "Yes ... Alex Skarsgard is getting a lot of attention - I think - because of Generation Kill and True Blood. I think the fan frenzy over him - which began when he wasn't even a big part of the True Blood episodes - has gotten Hollywood's attention. I also think he's the kind of actor who may get better looking as he ages. I mean when he was younger, he looked like a beautiful model and sorry to say - but American audiences like their male stars looking more manly. He a real actor from what I can see -- he knows how to do a lot by doing so little; he uses different voices depending on what he's saying and what emotion he's trying to get across - basically, he seems to be thinking about the craft. He also seems like a really nice guy - and this is important for a guy who needs to endear himself to executives and fans. So he pretty much has the raw package - let's see what he does with it. I hope he doesn't leave the show however no matter how big he gets because his True Blood character is the type of character than generally creates superstars! Do you find this valuable? |
|
Itsalltoomuch |
3608. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 2:31 PM EST
wow ! i'am late to the party today, but Doo i read your question & i cant wait to see if CH answers it.. i think that was a great question & well phrased.
Do you find this valuable?
|
|
Itsalltoomuch |
3609. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 3:31 PM EST
Hey Ms. Buffy Congrats on memeber of the week. but i have a question: do you recall which book Sookie notes that she allows Dean to come over & sleep? maybe Cat knows? a bloger on speculation 3 thread wants that info & i havent found it yet ( but i remeber that Sookie notes it in one of the books).. if you know can you post it please.. Do you find this valuable? |
|
msbuffy |
3610. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 4:59 PM EST
"Hey Ms. BuffyIt's in Dead Until Dark, Book #1. While Bill is out of town & Bubba is protecting Sookie from the serial killer (Rene), she finds the dog outside Merlottes by the dumpster, and Sookie being Sookie, she takes him home with her. She makes him sleep on the floor, but wakes in the morning to find his arm! draped over her - lo & behold, it's Sam!! I actually have a post-it marking that page right now, because I had remembered that you mentioned it the other day & I wanted to tell you about it!! I'm in the smoking room now (read - garage) so I can't tell you what it is. Thanks for the congrats! I had no idea what anyone was talking about until akel told me to look for!! LOL!! I never pay attention to those "True Blood Weekly" things!! Shame on me! Do you find this valuable? |
|
ms.starshine |
3611. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 5:56 PM EST
"It's in Dead Until Dark, Book #1. While Bill is out of town & Bubba is protecting Sookie from the serial killer (Rene), she finds the dog outside Merlottes by the dumpster, and Sookie being Sookie, she takes him home with her. She makes him sleep on the floor, but wakes in the morning to find his arm! draped over her - lo & behold, it's Sam!! I actually have a post-it marking that page right now, because I had remembered that you mentioned it the other day & I wanted to tell you about it!! I'm in the smoking room now (read - garage) so I can't tell you what it is.congratulations ms Buffy! I'm glad Itsall mentioned it because I don't read those weekly things either and would not have known. You should treat yourself to something to celebrate! Something chocolate always comes to mind. Do you find this valuable? |
|
ms.starshine |
3612. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 6:02 PM EST
"Yes ... Alex Skarsgard is getting a lot of attention - I think - because of Generation Kill and True Blood. I think the fan frenzy over him - which began when he wasn't even a big part of the True Blood episodes - has gotten Hollywood's attention. I also think he's the kind of actor who may get better looking as he ages. I mean when he was younger, he looked like a beautiful model and sorry to say - but American audiences like their male stars looking more manly. He a real actor from what I can see -- he knows how to do a lot by doing so little; he uses different voices depending on what he's saying and what emotion he's trying to get across - basically, he seems to be thinking about the craft. He also seems like a really nice guy - and this is important for a guy who needs to endear himself to executives and fans. So he pretty much has the raw package - let's see what he does with it.agree arwen. He seems to get the most fan attention and seems to be getting more significant roles in movies etc (though I hated the original Straw Dogs and probably won't see this new one) than any of the others. Plus my friend noted that Stephen Moyer and Anna P, being a real life couple, would probably stay with TB because it gives them a chance to work together for several months every year, which they will probably love. I hope he doesn't leave the show either -- at least not until after Season 4 and amnesia Eric. Do you find this valuable? |
|
arwenevenstarcroft |
3613. RE: BOOK 10 Speculation, and theory
Nov 6 2009, 6:16 PM EST
"agree arwen. He seems to get the most fan attention and seems to be getting more significant roles in movies etc (though I hated the original Straw Dogs and probably won't see this new one) than any of the others. Plus my friend noted that Stephen Moyer and Anna P, being a real life couple, would probably stay with TB because it gives them a chance to work together for several months every year, which they will probably love. I hope he doesn't leave the show either -- at least not until after Season 4 and amnesia Eric. "I think he has a sure thing with True Blood - he has the best character (if the writers stay true to the books). And his character should get hotter and hotter as the years go on. And there are 12 episodes per year - the average network show has 22 episodes. So he has time to do other projects. And I recently went to a SciFi/Horror/Comic convention and realized that actors who star in shows like True Blood can make a living for the rest of their lives -- for example, minor characters from Star Trek make a killing signing autographs at these conventions (people pay at least $40 per signed picture). Bottom line - there are archetypal characters that kick into high gear an actor's career and Alexander got such a role when they gave him the Eric part. Hope he and his handlers keep this in the back of their minds when they are consideration all the offers!! The offer better be exceptional if he chooses to walk away from True Blood!! Do you find this valuable? |